No kitchen is complete without a reliable set of food storage containers that hold up in all kinds of situations. Food containers need to be versatile, durable, and safe to use, whether you’re freezing, microwaving, stacking, or bringing them to the office. With so many choices on the market, how can you know which one is the right product for you? Finding the right storage containers for you isn’t as simple as you may think, and so many of us have made the mistake of buying the cheapest or most expensive products only to find that they can barely function in our kitchens. That’s why this guide is perfect for any storage enthusiast looking to invest in the best product available!
In this complete guide to the best food storage containers, Cleaning King breaks down the pros and cons of three of the most popular brands on the market: Tupperware vs Rubbermaid vs OXO food containers. To measure them up against each other, we’ll be looking at four essential criteria: tight seal, durability, ease of storage, and price to fully determine which one comes out on top.
There were four important things we considered when reviewing Tupperware vs Rubbermaid vs OXO food containers. Each criterion helps us understand and rank the popular food storage containers on the market, and they all contribute something important to the way we store our food.
When it comes to food storage, you want to look for something you can store (almost) anything in, from packed lunches to frozen broth. For that, you’ll want a food container that is completely airtight and leakproof. While most food container brands may advertise themselves as being airtight and leakproof, lower-quality storage containers will deteriorate faster than better containers. So while they may start out as perfectly safe for packing anything, that might not last. And soon enough, you’ll be dealing with a leaky food container that makes a mess in your bag, fridge, or freezer.
To ensure your food container has a seal that will last, we recommend choosing round containers instead of the typical rectangular or square containers. Corner seals are often the first to break down in a rectangular food container, so using round containers for things like liquids is often the better choice. Some brands have their own technology for creating a tight seal, and if a brand advertises its own proprietary technology, it is worth looking into it before you purchase.
Food storage containers go through a lot. We use, freeze, reheat, and stick them in a dishwasher in neverending cycles. We also use them to store all kinds of food—from red sauces to pungent dishes. That means two things: first, we want to make sure that our food storage containers are good at bouncing back and that a good wash will put them back in tip-top shape. The second is that they won’t easily break in the freezer or microwave or when we accidentally drop them on our kitchen floor.
Let’s tackle the age-old question of plastic vs glass when it comes to durability. Is one better than the other? It really depends on what’s more important to you. Glass is better in that it is less likely to scratch and stain, but some plastic food containers are more durable than you think. Plastic also has the advantage of being hard to break, so if you live with small children, you won’t have to worry about them breaking any food containers.
Food storage containers are always easy to store, right? Well, no, that’s not always the case. That might surprise you, but the truth is that many people don’t buy food storage containers to work together in a system. But if you’re serious about storage and organization, you will want to make sure that your food storage containers stack neatly and safely. That means choosing designs that easily fit each other to save space.
If you’re the type to misplace things easily or if you go to a lot of potlucks, you’ll also want to make sure that your food storage containers have lids that are easily interchangeable or replaceable. Dropping $50 on a high-quality food storage container could be a disaster if you lose the lid a month in and nothing else fits your fancy container. To avoid that problem, it’s almost always recommended to buy your storage containers from just one brand. So if you’re considering Tupperware vs Rubbermaid vs OXO food containers, make sure you’re happy with all their products!
How much should you really spend on a food storage container? It’ll really depend on what you need and what you expect from your food storage containers. Are you looking for something affordable to use for a year or two? Or are you looking for the best of the best that will last you years without breaking? Weigh the factors that are important for you before making a decision. For this guide, we took both the upfront cost as well as the product’s general longevity in mind when considering price.
Tupperware is the original king of food storage, so it is no wonder that their products are still people’s favorite all around the world. What started as an innovative idea for storing and preserving food with a sealed plastic container has ballooned to include everything from home organization to kitchen tools. Despite this, food storage containers remain the crown jewel of the Tupperware empire.
So what makes Tupperware products so special? Careful thought and rigorous product testing go into every product Tupperware creates. Their food storage containers are the ultimate do-it-all choice on the market. They’re freezer-safe, microwave-safe, and they are beautifully designed to make food storage a joy in the kitchen. Take their 7-piece Vent ‘N Serve Set, for instance. The deep blue tone of the containers is unique and chic that won’t scratch in the dishwasher. Because they look so cool, they’re perfect for people on the go whose meals go from the freezer to the microwave to the lunch table. The unique Tupperware plastic is also scratch and stain-resistant and so is perfect for busy homes.
The only con of the Tupperware brand is that they are on the higher end of the price spectrum for food storage containers. Because you are essentially paying for expertise and brand recognition, Tupperware products are often more expensive than similar products from other lesser-known brands.
Rubbermaid prioritizes practicality and durability over everything else in its products. Their products are secure and leakproof, available in a number of sizes and shapes to ensure everyone can use Rubbermaid products to organize their kitchens and preserve their food.
Rubbermaid expertly balances affordability and quality with its special plastic containers that look just like pricier glass containers. Their products are microwave-safe, dishwasher-safe, and freezer-safe and are thus the most versatile on this list. Not only can you store food in Rubbermaid containers, but you can also prep food ahead of time and freeze them safely. And when you’re ready to eat, Rubbermaid lids have a vent system to avoid messy splatters inside your microwave.
Their products are stain and odor-resistant and are very easy to clean, making them a great choice for a budget-conscious family looking for a food storage system that will last them a long time. Rubbermaid offers a range of food storage sets to satisfy every customer’s need. If this is your first time purchasing a Rubbermaid food storage kit, we recommend the 12-Piece Bento Box Style Lunch Kit. It has everything you could possibly need to prep meals ahead of time and stacks perfectly together to save space in your kitchen.
Perfect for: People who are looking for no-fuss products that are durable and reasonably priced
OXO food storage containers are the silent powerhouses that set the standard for high-quality glass containers on the market. Far from being costly, OXO Smart Seal Containers deliver incredible containers without breaking the bank. How do they do that? By sticking to a simple and reliable design. You won’t find OXO creating cutting-edge designs for their products and prefer to keep things the same to ensure reliability and interchangeability in their product lineup.
They offer one special feature that neither Rubbermaid nor Tupperware can offer in their products: OXO food storage containers are safe to use in the oven. So, in addition to being freezer, microwave, and dishwasher-safe, you can also quickly reheat food straight from the freezer in your oven. The smart seal on the products means that you won’t have to worry about leaks and spills when you take a container on the go.
OXO products are made with BPA-free glass that is stainproof and odor resistant, in addition to being easy to clean. It is important to be careful with glass containers, however. If you have small children in the home, keep them out of their reach to avoid accidents. They are also made to be easily stored, with similar sizes that are easily stacked. The best part? OXO products are reasonably priced, so you’ll be getting a great product without blowing your budget!
Perfect for: People looking for a more permanent food storage solution
In this product breakdown, we looked at four important factors that contribute to a great food storage container: a tight seal, durability, ease of storage, and price. We looked at Tupperware vs Rubbermaid vs OXO through the lens of these four things and have concluded that the best option among the three is Rubbermaid Brilliance Food Storage Containers.
Rubbermaid has a truly impressive range of products that cover everything from minimal food storage to serious food prep. Their products are made to last with strong plastic that looks just like glass and special lids that tightly seal any food you store. And while Tupperware and OXO bring their own unique approach to food storage to the table, you just can’t beat the affordability and durability of Rubbermaid!
“Why is Tupperware so expensive” is perhaps the most common question we hear about food storage containers. Tupperware quality is unquestionably excellent, but many people don’t realize that the brand is also reliable for replacements and repairs. That means that when you buy a Tupperware product, you can depend on a lifetime of customer service! Essentially, this quality and dedication to customer satisfaction are ultimately what you are paying for with Tupperware.
If you buy a high-quality food storage container and take care of it as instructed, you can expect your containers to last a lifetime. Many brands also offer a lifetime warranty for food storage containers and will replace any leaky or defective products. It is worth looking into long-term customer reviews of the product you wish to purchase to get an accurate idea of how long the container will last you.
Ten or twenty years ago, this question would be pretty straightforward. At the time, most people could agree that glass was better because it was generally stain-resistant and more durable. However, many brands have stepped up the quality of their plastic and many can now compete in both stain resistance and durability. So if you’re looking for something as durable as glass but not as delicate, plastic is a great option.