|Tru Earth||Earth Breeze||Dropps|
|Best for tough stains||Yes|
|Best for sensitive skin||Yes|
|Best for odor control||Yes|
|Best budget-friendly option||Yes|
|Best for long-lasting scents||Yes|
|Best for the environment||Yes|
|Cleaning Kings' Choice||Yes|
|Read our Review||Read our Review||Read our Review
|Buy on Amazon||Buy on Amazon||Buy on Amazon|
For the modern consumer shopping for laundry detergents, effectiveness and price are no longer the only things they consider when they choose their detergent. While the conversation on laundry products ten or twenty years ago might have centered around effectiveness and which product could deliver the best results, a new concern has arisen among laundry detergent buyers: environmental impact.
Households purchase laundry detergent at least on a monthly, sometimes on a bi-weekly basis if they are a particularly large household. And if you are purchasing liquid laundry detergents in large heavy plastic bottles that are non-reusable and non-recyclable, that waste can quickly build up. As we learn more about the environmental impact of plastic in landfills, it is no wonder that many people are turning to other companies to find better and more environmentally-friendly alternatives, like laundry sheets, strips, and pods that have a smaller environmental impact.
But just because a product advertises itself as an environmentally-friendly laundry detergent, that does not mean it is automatically worth purchasing. It is still important to investigate its effectiveness, ingredient list, and its suitability for all kinds of laundry. Not all laundry detergents are made equal, and it would be unfortunate to choose an environmentally-friendly product only to find out that not only did it do a poor job of washing your clothes, but it was also extremely expensive.
With this guide from Cleaning King, we have set out to review the three most popular alternative environmentally-friendly laundry detergent products on the market: Tru Earth Eco-Strips Laundry Detergent, Earth Breeze Laundry Detergent Eco-Sheets, and Dropps Laundry Detergent Pods. We’ll cover everything from effectiveness, scent, usability, cost, and of course, whether they can live up to their claim of being eco-friendly. Let the Tru Earth vs Earth Breeze vs Dropps match-up begin!
What makes a laundry detergent “good”? Laundry detergent products may all advertise to do the same thing, but we all know that they are not made equal. So what should you look for when you are buying a new laundry detergent to try out? Here are some things we consider important to your purchase:
The first thing you need to check before you purchase any laundry detergent is to make sure the product is compatible with the washing machine you own. High-efficiency washing machines, in particular, cannot accept all laundry detergents. Because HE washing machines work with less water, typical high-sudsing laundry detergents are incompatible with the laundry cycles the machine carries out. Always make sure you choose a laundry detergent that is marked as safe to use with HE washing machines, or you could end up with a proper mess on your hands.
Most laundry detergents come in one of these four categories: liquid, powder, pods, and sheets. Liquid and powder detergents have been around for at least the last century, but we are slowly seeing a shift toward more alternative forms of laundry detergent with the emergence and popularity of pod-style and sheet-based detergents. So what makes one better than the other?
The simple fact is that what detergent you choose to use will largely be dependent on your own preferences. Liquid and powder detergents tend to be cheaper, multi-purpose, and more widely available. On the other hand, pod and sheet detergents tend to be more expensive but are easier to use, more environmentally sustainable, and don’t generate as much mess as the former.
We’ve all experienced it at some point—you use a new laundry detergent and break out into itches and rashes the day you put your clean clothes on. Even if you haven’t experienced it yourself, you’ve probably heard about it from someone else. What is happening there is a skin reaction to the ingredients in a laundry detergent, particularly the ingredients that contribute to the scent of the detergent.
If you have sensitive skin, you’ll be better off using more environmentally friendly products that use plant-based vegan ingredients like laundry pods and sheets. These newer more environmentally conscious products also come in unscented variants for people who stay away from scents and are frustrated by the poor choice of unscented detergents in big supermarkets.
As we talked about earlier in this guide, more consumers than ever are weighing the environmental impact of the things they purchase, including laundry detergents. Laundry detergents have a large environmental impact because they are repurchased so often (and thus its packaging is tossed out more often) and the chemicals in these products eventually make their way into our water systems. Today, more than ever, consumers are thinking about what their laundry detergents are doing to the environment.
Now that you know what to look out for, how can we assess these three products according to the criteria we laid out? Let’s take a closer look at Tru Earth vs Earth Breeze vs Dropps through the lens of their washing machine compatibility, type, skin sensitivity, and environmental impact. At the end of this section, you should have a better grasp of what product is right for you.
When it comes to washing machine compatibility, all three of the products are compatible with HE washing machines. That means that whether you choose to buy Tru Earth Eco-Strips, Earth Breeze Eco-Sheets, or Dropps Laundry Detergent Pods, you will be able to use them with your high efficiency washing machines.
All three of these products are innovative in that they are neither powder nor liquid laundry detergents. Tru Earth and Earth Breeze use sheet-based laundry detergent technology while Dropps uses pod-based technology. All three are thus more convenient, as you simply have to toss them into an empty washing machine before adding your clothes. They are also less messy than both liquid and powder laundry detergents; there is no pre-measurement involved so you get the same result each and every time. However, the one advantage sheets have over pods is that they are extreme space-savers. While still smaller than typical liquid detergent bottles, laundry pods still take up more space than a pack of thin laundry sheets.
If you are worried about your skin breaking out to a new laundry detergent, any one of these three products should be safe to use with sensitive skin. All three are made with vegan ingredients and they are free from phosphates, dyes, and parabens that are often responsible for irritating sensitive skin. Additionally, with scented and unscented variants available from all three brands, you can opt for the unscented variant if you are particularly sensitive to fragrance or if you are worried about your children’s skin.
Finally, how environmentally friendly are these products? It is worth looking at each product carefully. Tru Earth Eco-Strips claim to be a completely eco-friendly product that has compostable packaging. However, Tru Earth does use minimal plastic packaging to keep the sheets safe from water damage. On the other hand, Earth Breeze completely does away with plastic packaging. Everything they use in their packaging is compostable to make the product waste-free. Dropps has a similar pledge to make everything compostable and waste-free. However, it is worth noting that 15,000 metric tons of intact PVA packaging make it to treatment facilities in the US every year.
Tru Earth Eco-Strips make a compelling argument for anyone thinking about switching over from liquid detergents to their products: in each 3g strip of Tru Earth detergent strip is the equivalent of 40g of premium liquid or powder detergent. That makes each strip enough for one medium-sized load of laundry. The formula washes away stains, dirt, and germs to completely clean your clothes. And with each packet of Tru Earth Eco -Strips containing 32 strips, they are a great alternative for people who are concerned about how effective non-liquid detergents are. You won’t have to keep rebuying, and if you do an average of two loads a week, there will still be enough in one package for 16 weeks! That’s a pretty good deal. And if you’re looking to save even more money, you can buy as many as 384 strips at once from Tru Earth. They also offer a subscription service that will keep you well-stocked throughout the year without worrying about running out.
Tru Earth laundry detergent strips work for almost all washing machines, including HE washing machines, top loader machines, and front loader machines. More importantly, these tiny strips of laundry detergent are really easy to use. There is no measuring involved and no mess, so all you need to do is toss one strip into the washing machine before you add your clothes. Even a total laundry novice will be able to handle this chore. They dissolve quickly in both hot and cold water, so you won’t have to worry about any clumps being left on your clothes or any clothes being left half-washed.
Tru Earth Eco-Strips Laundry Detergent are 100% vegan, phosphate-free, paraben-free, and are hypoallergenic. That makes them safe for sensitive skin which might otherwise be reactive to strong-scented products. And if you’re picky about scents, the good news is that Tru Earth has two options for their eco-strips: a linen-scented pack and an unscented pack. There is also a Platinum linen-scented variant that is formulated to be even more better-suited for heavy-duty cleaning.
So we know this product works, and we know it works well. But how accurate is the environmentally-friendly label on their packaging? Very accurate, as it turns out. Tru Earth is dedicated to perfecting a product that combines effectiveness, health, and care for the environment. Let’s look at the product packaging first. These strips come packaged in a compostable cardboard packet with all the information printed on it. While the strips are protected by a small plastic envelope, it is necessary to protect the sheets. Since they dissolve in water, the plastic envelope is an essential part of the packaging to stop any accidental dissolving. However, Tru Earth is working to figure out a new solution to make the packaging completely plastic-free to create a product that is 100% biodegradable. At the moment, however, this small amount of plastic is still better than the large plastic jugs liquid detergents often come in.L:
Paper sheets that somehow pack enough detergent to wash loads of laundry might seem like a completely impossible idea when you need so much liquid detergent to wash something, but the truth is that liquid detergents are not just detergent ingredients. In fact, liquid detergents can be 50-75% just water, so it makes sense to pack all those powerful ingredients into a small amount of space to save space and make things more convenient. Earth Breeze comes in such minimal packaging that you can fit 12 packs in the same space as 1 typically-sized plastic bottle of liquid detergent. But aside from size, how are sheets more convenient than a liquid detergent you can just pour into a washing machine?
Earth Breeze Laundry Sheets are easy to use and just as effective as the best liquid detergent on the market. They work for all machines, including HE machines, and all you need to do is add half a sheet to the machine for a regular load. Yes, half! They are so powerfully packed that just half a sheet is enough to clean, brighten, and remove stains from clothes in one regular load of laundry. You can even use them for handwashing clothes, as they quickly dissolve in both hot and cold water and are low-sudsing to stop things from getting too messy.
But even with an ultra-concentrated strong cleaning formula, Earth Breeze’s products are hypoallergenic, free from dangerous chemicals, and vegan. There are two variants of Earth Breeze detergent sheets that you can buy—a scented variant called Fresh and an unscented variant that is best for people with sensitive skin. Customer reviews are split on the scented version, with some people claiming that the Fresh scent only smells good when clothes are fresh from the machine but that they start to smell strange after a few hours. Reviews differ, so it is best to start with a small package of sheets to try for yourself.
Unlike other similar products that are not 100% plastic-free, Earth Breeze prides itself on having 100% plastic-free packaging. The sheets come in a cardboard sleeve that is completely biodegradable to help lower your carbon footprint. With Earth Breeze, you are able to completely cut plastic out of your laundry ritual, making it a great choice for people who prioritize environmental impact over everything else.
Each packet of Earth Breeze Laundry Detergent Eco Sheets has 30 sheets, which is enough for 60 regular loads of laundry. If you have a larger load of laundry, 1 sheet is enough to completely clean your clothes. And if you have a very large load of laundry or have an extra-soiled load of laundry (for example, clothes from a camping trip), then 2 sheets will more than do the job. You can either buy each packet separately for $20 from Earth Breeze’s website or subscribe to a monthly plan and save 40% on each packet. The subscription plan is a better deal if you are a household that does many laundry loads each month. So while Earth Breeze may seem more expensive, Earth Breeze’s subscription has made it easier to fit the product into your budget.
If you have used Tide Pods before, you should already be familiar with the innovative technology behind laundry pods. Laundry pods like Dropps pack a powerful liquid detergent into a small pod made from a film that dissolves in both cold and hot water. What makes Dropps different is that the pods are packaged in a compostable box instead of a big plastic tub like the Tide variant. That makes them more environmentally friendly and waste-free.
Dropps pods are smaller than major competitors but are just as good at removing scents, eliminating odors, and brightening clothes without damaging the fabric. One pod is enough for one load of laundry, and they work for all kinds of washing machines. The vegan plant-based formula is free from dyes, phosphates, and parabens to be suitable for sensitive skin. Dropps Laundry Detergent Pods come in four variants: Clean & Crisp, Lavender Eucalyptus, Orange Blosson, and an unscented version. The scents are plant-based but last longer than many other natural laundry detergents. And if you are someone who works an active job or loves to work out, Dropps also offers an Active formula that works even better at removing stains and odors.
Dropps is committed to helping the environment. That is why it makes its products to be 100% waste-free in the USA. To make things even more convenient for its customers, Dropps offers various subscription packages. Whether you choose to subscribe to their 56, 140, or 210 box subscription, you can save 25% to save money on your laundry products. Dropps pods are more expensive straight-up than other similar products like Tide Pods, so if you want to save some money while still saving the environment, a subscription plan might work for you.
In this guide to Tru Earth vs Earth Breeze vs Dropps laundry detergent, we broke down their features based on several important criteria: washing machine compatibility, type, sensitivity and ingredients, and environmental impact.
Based on these factors, Cleaning King is confident in recommending Earth Breeze Laundry Detergent Eco-Sheets to our readers. Earth Breeze ticks all the boxes: it is effective against stubborn stains and strong odors, is hypoallergenic and free from harmful chemicals and comes in 100% plastic-free packaging. For these reasons, Cleaning King recommends this product over both Tru Earth and Dropps, which while still good products, are not as great all-around as Earth Breeze’s line of laundry detergents.
Earth Breeze is a startup company dedicated to the mission of creating environmentally-friendly alternatives to common household items, starting with laundry detergents. Earth Breeze has a multi-layer production process. Ingredients are sourced in Asia and processed in China. They are then brought to the USA where they are packaged and sent to customers and official retailers in other countries. Earth Breeze offers free shipping in the USA and UK. Despite the sheets being currently manufactured in China, Earth Breeze has plans to create the sheets in the USA to make the product more sustainable.
Many people who are thinking of making the switch from liquid detergents to pod detergents worry that these small packages are not enough to break down grease and odors. However, the ultra-concentrated formula of laundry pods actually makes them more effective at dealing with grease compared to a cup full of liquid detergent.